We continue with our Civil Procedure Reform Observatory. In the previous chapter, we reviewed the various positions a defendant may take in response to a complaint. Now we’ll take a closer look at two of them: default and admission of the claim.
The question is simple but relevant: What happens if the defendant fails to appear or does not contest the claim?
Two different situations
A default judgment is issued when a defendant who has been duly summoned fails to appear within the prescribed time limit. An admission of claim, on the other hand, means that the defendant accepts, in whole or in part, the claim made by the plaintiff. Both of these concepts already exist in our civil procedure, but the bill establishes specific rules for them.
Article 264: Regulations Governing Default
The text approved by the Chamber of Deputies in 2014 contains an explicit provision on this point. Article 264 states that if the defendant fails to file an answer to the complaint, the court shall deem the answer to have been filed, and the proceedings shall continue in the defendant’s absence, by operation of law.
First effect: Rebellion amounts to a denial of the facts
Article 264 itself provides that a failure to appear shall be deemed a denial of the facts alleged by the plaintiff. In other words, the bill expressly states that a failure to appear does not constitute an admission of the facts alleged in the complaint.
Second effect: the "rebel's evidence" rule is restricted
Furthermore, pursuant to Article 264, a defendant who fails to appear may not present evidence at trial, except in the manner and under the conditions set forth in Article 276. This provision allows a party to allege new and relevant facts, or facts that the party could not and should not have known about previously, by presenting the necessary evidence to substantiate them. These facts may be alleged during the proceedings, in writing, or no later than at the preliminary hearing.
Can the rebel intervene at a later time?
Yes. Article 264 of the 2014 Chamber Act allows a defendant who has failed to appear to appear at any stage of the proceedings, provided that the proceedings conducted previously are respected: a subsequent appearance does not allow for a reversal of the proceedings that have already taken place.
With regard to service of process, the general rule is that it is not necessary to serve subsequent rulings on the defaulting party, as they take effect upon issuance. There are, however, two exceptions: the order summoning the party to the preliminary hearing and the final judgment of the court of first instance must be served by certified notice.
Article 266: Regulations Governing Searches
With regard to admission of the claim, Article 266 of the 2014 Chamber text states that the defendant may admit the claim—accepting it in whole or in part—in its answer or, subsequently, at the preliminary hearing.
Its effects depend on the type of uncontested claim. In the case of a full uncontested claim, or when the defendant does not dispute the facts alleged by the plaintiff on substantive and relevant grounds, the court must issue a final judgment once the preliminary hearing has concluded, without the need for evidence or any other proceedings.
However, the proceedings must continue if the search is partial, if the matter concerns public order, or if it involves inalienable rights.
What has changed compared to the current CPC?
With regard to default, the current CPC does not consider a failure to respond to be equivalent to an admission of the facts, and default alone does not preclude the presentation of evidence at the appropriate time. The bill, on the other hand, establishes that failure to respond constitutes a denial of the facts and expressly restricts the evidence of the defaulting party, subjecting it to the provisions of Article 276. In addition, it includes a special rule regarding service of process, with two service attempts per notice.
With regard to the search, Article 313 of the current Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) allows for the omission of the hearing on the merits and for the parties to be summoned to hear the judgment, subject to certain conditions. Article 266 of the draft bill, for its part, links the rendering of the judgment to the preliminary hearing in the cases provided for therein.
Well-known rules, now expressly regulated
The novelty, then, does not lie in establishing a default or an admission of liability, but rather in expressly regulating their effects within the new procedural model. Among the revisions, the evidentiary limitations on a defendant who defaults are the point that deserves particular attention. In summary: the bill stipulates in the legal text what happens when the defendant fails to appear or admits liability, and links both situations to the preliminary hearing.
* This is a bill currently under consideration, so its content may change before its final publication. The cited sections (264, 266, and 276) correspond to the text approved by the Chamber of Deputies in 2014, subject to any changes in section numbering resulting from subsequent amendments.